What’s up with Prefrontal Cortex?

A Commentary on John-Dylan Haynes

Commentator

Caspar M. Schwiedrzik

cschwiedrz @ rockefeller.edu

The Rockefeller University

New York, NY, U.S.A.

Target Author

John-Dylan Haynes

haynes @ bccn-berlin.de

Charité – Universitätsmedizin Berlin

Berlin, Germany

Editors

Thomas Metzinger

metzinger @ uni-mainz.de

Johannes Gutenberg-Universität

Mainz, Germany

Jennifer M. Windt

jennifer.windt @ monash.edu

Monash University

Melbourne, Australia

The prefrontal cortex is perhaps one of the most intriguing areas of the brain, and considered by many to be involved in a whole battery of higher cognitive functions. However, evidence for a direct involvement in conscious perception, although often postulated, remains inconclusive. In his paper, John-Dylan Haynes presents results from experiments using multivariate decoding techniques on human functional magnetic resonance imaging data that speak against the assertion that prefrontal cortex broadcasts the contents of consciousness throughout the brain. I consider potential reasons for these null results, as well as where else we may look for the neural correlates of consciousness. Specifically, I propose that conscious perception arises when distributed neurons are bound into coherent assemblies—a process that does not require relay through specific brain areas.

Keywords

Multivariate pattern analysis | Neuronal correlates of consciousness | Neuronal synchrony | Prefrontal cortex