The Representational Structure of Feelings

Author

Joëlle Proust

joelle.proust @ ehess.fr

Ecole Normale Supérieure

Paris, France

Commentator

Iuliia Pliushch

pliushi @ students.uni-mainz.de

Johannes Gutenberg-Unversität

Mainz, Germany

Editors

Thomas Metzinger

metzinger @ uni-mainz.de

Johannes Gutenberg-Universität

Mainz, Germany

Jennifer M. Windt

jennifer.windt @ monash.edu

Monash University

Melbourne, Australia

The word “feeling” denotes a reactive, subjective experience with a distinctive embodied phenomenal quality. Several types of feelings are usually distinguished, such as bodily, agentive, affective, and metacognitive feelings. The hypothesis developed in this article is that all feelings are represented in a specialized, non-conceptual “expressive” mode, whose function is evaluative and action-guiding. Feelings, it is claimed, are conceptually impenetrable. Against a two-factor theory of feelings, it is argued, in the cases of affective and metacognitive feelings, that background beliefs can circumvent feelings in gaining the control of action, but cannot fully suppress them or their motivational potential.

Keywords

Affective feelings | Affordance | Agentive feelings | Appraisal | Arousal | Bodily feelings | Comparator | Control | Cues | Evaluative | Expressive | Familiarity | Fluency | Formal object | Illusory feeling | Incidental feelings | Integral feelings | Intensity | Metacognitive or noetic feelings | Monitoring | Nonconceptual content | Predictive | Reactive | Resonance | Retrospective | Somatic marker | Transparency | Two-factor account | Valence